fresh to death

HIgh Quality Ingredients

We believe in using fresh, high quality ingredients while always MAXIMIZING flavor and taste!

SHOP cookies

Treat Yourself

freshly baked goodies!

Our bakers simply do not know how one can compromise a quality for any reason.


How to Order

Every Thursday at 6PM we update our inventory weekly and sell until we're sold out! Don't miss out on your delicious batch today.

Menu is Live every Thursday 6pm est Hurry We sell Out fast!

Our menus are live every Thursday at 6PM EST and will be available for nationwide delivery until we sell out!

shop cookies

More About Us

Who We Are

It all started with one cookie, family, and a first responder. Learn More about how Fat Paulie's Cookies came to be and why our cookies are the worst kept secret on the internet today.


Our frequently asked questions can help you navigate everything from our ingredients, to shipping and more. Check out our FAQs if you have any questions before you purchase.

Get In Touch

For more information on larger wholesale orders or if you have general questions, please contact us at for further assistance.

"The Best Cookies Hands Down."

Joey S. - Valued Customer

"The taste is unreal! A must try!"

Jessica M.

"It's like grandma's cookies on steroids!"

Kyle M.