It appears that your cart is currently empty
Menu is live Every Thursday at 6:00PM EST
How to Order
Every Thursday at 6PM we update our inventory weekly and sell until we're sold out! Don't miss out on your delicious batch today.
the goods!
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 8 cookies box, holiday pac...
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 8 cookies box, holiday packaging, and custom card with message! (use notes for card message)
$35.00
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 20 cookies box, holiday pa...
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 20 cookies box, holiday packaging, and custom card with message! (use notes for card message)
$85.00
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 12 cookies box, holiday pa...
Holiday Gift Box to send to a loved one, customer, or friend! Includes 12 cookies box, holiday packaging, and custom card with message! (use notes for card message)
$52.00
More About Us
Who We Are
It all started with one cookie, family, and a first responder. Learn More about how Fat Paulie's Cookies came to be and why our cookies are the worst kept secret on the internet today.
FAQs
Our frequently asked questions can help you navigate everything from our ingredients, to shipping and more. Check out our FAQs if you have any questions before you purchase.
Get In Touch
For more information on larger wholesale orders or if you have general questions, please contact us at sales@fatpauliescookies.com for further assistance.